A driver — enraged by a teenager accidentally clipping her wing mirror pursued a 16-year-old cyclist and smashed her vehicle into the boy's bike, knocking him to the ground with facial injuries — has walked away from court with a suspended sentence.

Phoebe Groves pleaded guilty to assault occasioning actual bodily harm and dangerous driving, and was told by the judge at Teesside Crown Court that it is "highly unusual" for a driver to avoid immediate jail time in such circumstances, but was handed a 12-month sentence suspended for two years and a 12-month driving ban, as well as 150 hours of unpaid work and 40 rehabilitation activity requirement days.

The Northern Echo (link is external) reports judge Timothy Stead was shown CCTV footage of Groves, 22, ramming her Vauxhall Astra into the 16-year-old as he pulled up outside his house on Fabian Road, Middlesbrough, at just after 8pm on 7 August 2021.

The impact threw the teenager into the air before he landed on the footpath, suffering grazing to his face and swelling around both eyes, and came after Groves had pursued the cyclist, angered by a friend of his who had accidentally clipped her vehicle's wing mirror moments earlier.

At sentencing, prosecutor Jon Harley told the judge the boy had suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder as a result of Groves' assault, while in her victim impact statement the boy's mother said he "is not the same person anymore" and never leaves the house and barely takes care of himself.

Describing the attack, Mr Harley said the boy "was hit from behind by the vehicle driven by the defendant. He was thrown from his bike and he hit the pavement before the car drove off."

In mitigation, Rod Hunt suggested his client was "not at the time, in her right mind" and argued Groves had suffered a "brainstorm" when she became enraged by the contact with her wing mirror. He also stressed that Groves had returned to the scene after initially driving off.

"You have heard me say that people who come before this court for using a vehicle as a weapon deliberately and cause injury, almost always will go immediately to prison," judge Stead told her.

"I know that you know that what you did was very wrong, I believe that you are deeply sorry for it.

"Your case is exceptional. (NO IT IS NOT - ALL TOO COMMON)

"If you do breach the order within the next two years, and I don't believe that you will, then the court will start with the suspended sentence and then will include anything else."

https://road.cc/content/news/driver-who-rammed-teenage-cyclist-bike-avoids-jail-299641

Choose one’s friends with more care, perhaps…

swldx...@gmail.com <swldxer1958@gmail.com> wrote:
> A driver — enraged by a teenager accidentally clipping her wing mirror
> pursued a 16-year-old cyclist and smashed her vehicle into the boy's
> bike, knocking him to the ground with facial injuries — has walked away
> from court with a suspended sentence.
>
> Phoebe Groves pleaded guilty to assault occasioning actual bodily harm
> and dangerous driving, and was told by the judge at Teesside Crown Court
> that it is "highly unusual" for a driver to avoid immediate jail time in
> such circumstances, but was handed a 12-month sentence suspended for two
> years and a 12-month driving ban, as well as 150 hours of unpaid work and
> 40 rehabilitation activity requirement days.
>
> The Northern Echo (link is external) reports judge Timothy Stead was
> shown CCTV footage of Groves, 22, ramming her Vauxhall Astra into the
> 16-year-old as he pulled up outside his house on Fabian Road,
> Middlesbrough, at just after 8pm on 7 August 2021.
>
> The impact threw the teenager into the air before he landed on the
> footpath, suffering grazing to his face and swelling around both eyes,
> and came after Groves had pursued the cyclist, angered by a friend of his
> who had accidentally clipped her vehicle's wing mirror moments earlier.
>
> At sentencing, prosecutor Jon Harley told the judge the boy had suffered
> from post-traumatic stress disorder as a result of Groves' assault, while
> in her victim impact statement the boy's mother said he "is not the same
> person anymore" and never leaves the house and barely takes care of himself.
>
> Describing the attack, Mr Harley said the boy "was hit from behind by the
> vehicle driven by the defendant. He was thrown from his bike and he hit
> the pavement before the car drove off."
>
> In mitigation, Rod Hunt suggested his client was "not at the time, in her
> right mind" and argued Groves had suffered a "brainstorm" when she became
> enraged by the contact with her wing mirror. He also stressed that Groves
> had returned to the scene after initially driving off.
>
> "You have heard me say that people who come before this court for using a
> vehicle as a weapon deliberately and cause injury, almost always will go
> immediately to prison," judge Stead told her.
>
> "I know that you know that what you did was very wrong, I believe that
> you are deeply sorry for it.
>
> "Your case is exceptional. (NO IT IS NOT - ALL TOO COMMON)
>
> "If you do breach the order within the next two years, and I don't
> believe that you will, then the court will start with the suspended
> sentence and then will include anything else."
>
> https://road.cc/content/news/driver-who-rammed-teenage-cyclist-bike-avoids-jail-299641
>

--
Spike

Your case is exceptional.

well..... If the case is exceptional it seems more aggravating than mitigating.

1) the victim was a minor

2) the driver hit the stationary victim from behind witha a car FFS

3) there was a pursuit, time in which the defendant could have calmed down, but didn't