A US court said Spain could keep a priceless painting looted by the Nazis
from its Jewish owner.

The decadeslong court battle has been watched closely as a landmark case
in art restitution.

One of the judges said she agreed with the decision but it still went
against her "moral compass."

A priceless painting looted by the Nazis that ended up in a Spanish museum
does not have to be returned to the family of its original Jewish owner, a
trio of judges has ruled.

Tuesday's court decision, in what is perhaps the highest-profile case of
World War II art restitution, shocked the family and even prompted one of
the judges to say it went against her "moral compass."

In 1939, while attempting to flee Germany, the Jewish art collector Lilly
Neubauer was forced by the Nazis to sell the impressionist Camille
Pissarro's painting "Rue Saint-Honor� in the Afternoon. Effect of Rain."

She was never allowed access to the bank account the fee was paid into,
according to court documents seen by Business Insider.

The painting, of a muted, rainy street scene in Paris, was created in 1897
and shows the view from Pissarro's hotel window, according to Madrid's
Museo Nacional Thyssen-Bornemisza, which holds the painting today.

Following the war, a US court of restitution appeals ruled that Neubauer
remained the owner of the painting, which she believed was lost or
destroyed. The German government paid Neubauer the painting's value at the
time � the equivalent of about $250,000 in today's money � in restitution.

Today, the painting is estimated to be worth about $30 million, The
Guardian reported.

After changing hands multiple times, the painting ended up being bought by
a Spanish noble, Baron Hans Heinrich Thyssen-Bornemisza, whose art
collection is now the property of a state-backed Spanish nonprofit named
after him.

In 2000, one of Neubauer's descendants, the California resident Claude
Cassirer, found out the painting was on display in Madrid's Museo Nacional
Thyssen-Bornemisza and requested it back � but Spain refused.

Litigation around the painting has taken place ever since.

The decadeslong case gained further prominence in April 2022, when the US
Supreme Court reopened it, sending it back to California's 9th US Circuit
Court of Appeals, the trade outlet The Art Newspaper reported at the time.

Judges there said the determination would rest on whose law applied in
this case � Spain's or California's. The Spanish-backed nonprofit didn't
know the painting was looted when it bought the collection, the judges
said, giving it a stronger claim within Spanish law.

"Under California law the plaintiffs would recover the art, while under
Spanish law they would not," they wrote.

Ultimately, the decision rested, they said, on whose interests would be
more damaged by the decision going against them.

"The panel concluded that, under the facts of this case, Spain's
governmental interests would be more impaired by the application of
California law than would California's governmental interests be impaired
by the application of Spanish law," they wrote. "Thus, Spanish law must
apply."

The decision has "surprised and disappointed" the family, Sam Dubbin,
their attorney, told the Los Angeles Times.

The decision "fails to explain how Spain has any interest in applying its
laws to launder ownership of the spoils of war," the family's lawyers said
in a statement seen by the paper.

The statement added: "The Cassirers believe that, especially in light of
the explosion of antisemitism in this country and around the world today,
they must challenge Spain's continuing insistence on harboring Nazi looted
art."

The museum welcomed the decision. It argued that neither the Spanish
state-backed nonprofit nor Thyssen-Bornemisza knew the painting was stolen
when he bought it.

The family disputed this, saying he should have done more due diligence,
the Times reported.

One of the judges, Consuelo Callahan, said that while she agreed with the
decision, it conflicted with her "moral compass," the statement said.

It added that she believed "Spain should have voluntarily relinquished the
painting."

https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/nazis-forced-jewish-woman-hand-
154413066.html