novaBBS - alt.education - Re: Pedophile school's transgender policy trumped teacher's religious rights, U.S. court rules

Re: Pedophile school's transgender policy trumped teacher's religious rights, U.S. court rules

<c72f92392396e649f3da1708e8e4c161@dizum.com>

https://www.novabbs.com/interests/article-flat.php?id=1296&group=alt.education#1296

copy link Newsgroups: alt.education alt.fan.rush-limbaugh alt.transgendered sac.politics talk.politics.guns

Date: Thu, 13 Apr 2023 01:18:32 +0200 (CEST)
Path: i2pn2.org!rocksolid2!news.neodome.net!mail2news
Injection-Info: neodome.net;
posting-account="mail2news";
key="bRlZz+DFJg1D1oWP1w0FkAXPDmLZEUPVKTbePoKXT3pBx2E6yvrlBGXinJxfMV8VVhVTII
+pjMbbzbwEjKj7JhvZc7gfAmG3DFayP03wHbGTXRaHH4X/SVJ/B4sy6uwOUYw5rmszL6t1pxD2q
WdPHkBnjmLxsLkmGP85VuMeZuFBPF9t2D2GiIU+PtoZA3c3j7GtOmzR7NE8wxZBJGctxFIRBELO
eP56ms5O3eGPCSOyZgSvbveKvA2qZ+wk2yUdxLXBpn6irBiPZCQiImflfAHawn8skooUYNgFA/s
699OVXWEp44GYfXn2Y83LyqfYnTucQOcul8+uxpQh+3z/RA==";
data="U2FsdGVkX19evLBbPHrgOWqr9LE/KIreeIheoDMS0PRoXAHVtqXZNDgS3FFoArht6yjhN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=
";
mail-complaints-to="abuse@neodome.net"
From: libtar...@nytimes.com (Libtardia)
References: <tKuvI.26270$G11.23897@fx01.iad> <s9mdki$1igc$1@neodome.net> <almarsoft.609707982057328901@news.easynews.com> <s9muid$oep$2@neodome.net>
Comments: This message did not originate from the Sender address above.
It was remailed automatically by anonymizing remailer software.
Please report problems or inappropriate use to the
remailer administrator at <abuse@dizum.com>.
Comments: This message was transferred to Usenet via mail2news gateway at
<mail2news@neodome.net>. Please send questions and concerns to
<admin@neodome.net>. Report inappropriate use to <abuse@neodome.net>.
Subject: Re: Pedophile school's transgender policy trumped teacher's religious rights, U.S. court rules
Injection-Date: Wed, 12 Apr 2023 23:20:01 +0000 (UTC)
Sender: Nomen Nescio <nobody@dizum.com>
Message-ID: <c72f92392396e649f3da1708e8e4c161@dizum.com>
Newsgroups: alt.education,alt.fan.rush-limbaugh,alt.transgendered,sac.politics,talk.politics.guns

by: Libtardia - Wed, 12 Apr 2023 23:18 UTC

On 07 Jun 2021, Rudy Canoza <j__carlson@gmx.com> posted some
news:s9muid$oep$2@neodome.net:

> That fucking court is wrong. Every judge who ruled against the
> teacher should be shot.

(Reuters) - An Indiana high school did not break the law by allegedly
forcing a music teacher to quit after he refused on religious grounds to
use transgender students' preferred names, a U.S. appeals court ruled on
Friday.

The rights of the teacher, John Kluge, to exercise his religious beliefs
were outweighed by the potential disruption that his conduct could have on
the learning environment at Brownsburg High School in the Indianapolis
suburbs, the Chicago-based 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said.

Kluge said his Christian religious beliefs barred him from complying with
a school policy requiring faculty to use students' preferred names and
pronouns.

The school initially allowed Kluge to call students by their last names
but reneged after receiving complaints from students and faculty,
according to court filings. He said he resigned in 2018 after he was told
he would be fired.

Kluge sued the school district in 2019, accusing it of violating a federal
law that prohibits workplace discrimination based on religion. He was
seeking to get his job back and unspecified money damages.

Kluge is represented by the Alliance Defending Freedom, a conservative
Christian legal group. Rory Gray, a lawyer with the group, said he was
evaluating Kluge's options.

�The 7th Circuit�s ruling shows why the Supreme Court needs to fix the
standard for accommodating religious employees," Gray said in a statement.

Lawyers for the school did not respond to a request for comment.

Federal law only requires employers to accommodate workers' religious
beliefs if it would not cause them an undue hardship.

Kluge in his lawsuit argued that allowing him to call students by their
last names would not create a burden for the school.

The 7th Circuit on Friday disagreed, upholding an Indiana federal judge's
ruling that dismissed the case.

"Kluge's last-names-only practice stigmatized the transgender students and
caused them demonstrable emotional harm," Circuit Judge Ilana Rovner wrote
for the court.

In a dissenting opinion, Circuit Judge Michael Brennan said it was unclear
whether the school could have mitigated any disruptions resulting from
Kluge's conduct, and that a jury should decide whether his rights were
violated.

(Reporting by Daniel Wiessner in Albany, New York, Editing by Alexia
Garamfalvi, Rosalba O'Brien and David Gregorio)

<https://news.yahoo.com/schools-transgender-policy-trumped-teachers-
210841914.html>

Subject	Author
Re: Pedophile school's transgender policy trumped teacher's religious rights, U.	Libtardia

God must love the common man; He made so many of them.

interests / alt.education / Re: Pedophile school's transgender policy trumped teacher's religious rights, U.S. court rules