I went to a mechanic, part of a large chain of mechanics, and got some
work done they said needed doing (rear shocks).

When I picked up the car the speakers didn't work anymore.

I took the car to a car audio guy and he said something has damaged the
rear speakers. I said the mechanic replaced the rear shocks, and he
said it must have been when that happened.

Can I demand the mechanic pays the cost of the speaker replacement, due
to the mechanic having broken the speakers, according to the car audio guy?

On 26-Sept-22 2:48 pm, Max wrote:
> I went to a mechanic, part of a large chain of mechanics, and got some
> work done they said needed doing (rear shocks).
>
> When I picked up the car the speakers didn't work anymore.
>
> I took the car to a car audio guy and he said something has damaged the
> rear speakers.  I said the mechanic replaced the rear shocks, and he
> said it must have been when that happened.
>
> Can I demand the mechanic pays the cost of the speaker replacement, due
> to the mechanic having broken the speakers, according to the car audio guy?

You can demand. Whether it happens is a different matter.

"Something has damaged" is rather vague. It doesn't sound like your
audio guy knows what is wrong with them. Are you sure they didn't just
get unplugged during the work, with the mechanic forgetting to plug them
back in?

"It didn't work" may be good enough for Windows 10 error messages, but
usually we need more.

To pursue this, you would need to get an independent report on the
nature of the damage to the speakers, how that could reasonably relate
to the replacement of the shock absorbers, and an estimate of the costs
of repairs.

Sylvia.

Max <max@val.morgan> wrote

> I went to a mechanic, part of a large chain of mechanics, and got some
> work done they said needed doing (rear shocks).

> When I picked up the car the speakers didn't work anymore.

> I took the car to a car audio guy and he said something has damaged the
> rear speakers. I said the mechanic replaced the rear shocks, and he
> said it must have been when that happened.

SURE you did.

> Can I demand the mechanic pays the cost of the speaker replacement, due
> to the mechanic having broken the speakers, according to the car audio
> guy?

Its bullshit, replacing the rear shocks wouldnt fuck the speakers.

Retake Trolling 101

On 26/09/2022 3:24 pm, Rod Speed wrote:
> Max <max@val.morgan> wrote
>
>> I went to a mechanic, part of a large chain of mechanics, and got some
>> work done they said needed doing (rear shocks).
>
>> When I picked up the car the speakers didn't work anymore.
>
>> I took the car to a car audio guy and he said something has damaged
>> the rear speakers.  I said the mechanic replaced the rear shocks, and
>> he said it must have been when that happened.
>
> SURE you did.
>
>> Can I demand the mechanic pays the cost of the speaker replacement,
>> due to the mechanic having broken the speakers, according to the car
>> audio  guy?
>
> Its bullshit, replacing the rear shocks wouldnt fuck the speakers.
>

The rear shocks are near the rear speakers. It's likely the mechanic
was rough trying to access the shocks and damaged the speakers.

> Retake Trolling 101

Max <max@val.morgan> wrote
> Rod Speed wrote
>> Max <max@val.morgan> wrote

>>> I went to a mechanic, part of a large chain of mechanics, and got some
>>> work done they said needed doing (rear shocks).

>>> When I picked up the car the speakers didn't work anymore.

>>> I took the car to a car audio guy and he said something has damaged
>>> the rear speakers. I said the mechanic replaced the rear shocks, and
>>> he said it must have been when that happened.

>> SURE you did.

>>> Can I demand the mechanic pays the cost of the speaker replacement,
>>> due to the mechanic having broken the speakers, according to the car
>>> audio guy?

>> Its bullshit, replacing the rear shocks wouldnt fuck the speakers.

> The rear shocks are near the rear speakers. It's likely the mechanic
> was rough trying to access the shocks and damaged the speakers.

Pity the speakers are inside the car and the shocks arent.

Retake Trolling 101

On 27/09/2022 11:57 am, Rod Speed wrote:
> Max <max@val.morgan> wrote
>> Rod Speed wrote
>>> Max <max@val.morgan> wrote
>
>>>> I went to a mechanic, part of a large chain of mechanics, and got
>>>> some work done they said needed doing (rear shocks).
>
>>>> When I picked up the car the speakers didn't work anymore.
>
>>>> I took the car to a car audio guy and he said something has damaged
>>>> the rear speakers.  I said the mechanic replaced the rear shocks,
>>>> and he said it must have been when that happened.
>
>>>  SURE you did.
>
>>>> Can I demand the mechanic pays the cost of the speaker replacement,
>>>> due to the mechanic having broken the speakers, according to the car
>>>> audio  guy?
>
>>>  Its bullshit, replacing the rear shocks wouldnt fuck the speakers.
>
>> The rear shocks are near the rear speakers.  It's likely the mechanic
>> was rough trying to access the shocks and damaged the speakers.
>
> Pity the speakers are inside the car and the shocks arent.
>

The car audio guy it must have been the mechanic. The part of the car
where you get to the shocks is close the speakers, so they must have
been very rough with it.

The car audio guy said it was as though there had been a fire in that
area of the car.

Since the speakers only didn't work after I picked up the car from the
mechanic, it is too much of a coincidence that wasn't the mechanic who
broke the speakers.

> Retake Trolling 101

Max <max@val.morgan> wrote
> Rod Speed wrote
>> Max <max@val.morgan> wrote
>>> Rod Speed wrote
>>>> Max <max@val.morgan> wrote

>>>>> I went to a mechanic, part of a large chain of mechanics, and got
>>>>> some work done they said needed doing (rear shocks).
>>
>>>>> When I picked up the car the speakers didn't work anymore.
>>
>>>>> I took the car to a car audio guy and he said something has damaged
>>>>> the rear speakers. I said the mechanic replaced the rear shocks,
>>>>> and he said it must have been when that happened.
>>
>>>> SURE you did.
>>
>>>>> Can I demand the mechanic pays the cost of the speaker replacement,
>>>>> due to the mechanic having broken the speakers, according to the car
>>>>> audio guy?
>>
>>>> Its bullshit, replacing the rear shocks wouldnt fuck the speakers.
>>
>>> The rear shocks are near the rear speakers. It's likely the mechanic
>>> was rough trying to access the shocks and damaged the speakers.

>> Pity the speakers are inside the car and the shocks arent.

> The car audio guy it must have been the mechanic.

If that individual even exists, he's a fuckwit.

> The part of the car where you get to the shocks is close thespeakers,
> so they must have been very rough with it.

Not even possible with the shocks outside
the car and the speakers inside it, fuckwit.

> The car audio guy said it was as though therehad been a fire in that
> area of the car.

Retake Trolling 101

> Since the speakers only didn't work after I picked up the car from the
> mechanic, it is too much of a coincidence that wasn't the mechanic who
> broke the speakers.

Retake Trolling 101

On 27/09/2022 7:12 pm, Rod Speed wrote:
> Max <max@val.morgan> wrote
>> Rod Speed wrote
>>> Max <max@val.morgan> wrote
>>>> Rod Speed wrote
>>>>> Max <max@val.morgan> wrote
>
>>>>>> I went to a mechanic, part of a large chain of mechanics, and got
>>>>>> some work done they said needed doing (rear shocks).
>>>
>>>>>> When I picked up the car the speakers didn't work anymore.
>>>
>>>>>> I took the car to a car audio guy and he said something has
>>>>>> damaged the rear speakers.  I said the mechanic replaced the rear
>>>>>> shocks, and he said it must have been when that happened.
>>>
>>>>>  SURE you did.
>>>
>>>>>> Can I demand the mechanic pays the cost of the speaker
>>>>>> replacement, due to the mechanic having broken the speakers,
>>>>>> according to the car audio  guy?
>>>
>>>>>  Its bullshit, replacing the rear shocks wouldnt fuck the speakers.
>>>
>>>> The rear shocks are near the rear speakers.  It's likely the
>>>> mechanic was rough trying to access the shocks and damaged the
>>>> speakers.
>
>>>  Pity the speakers are inside the car and the shocks arent.
>
>> The car audio guy it must have been the mechanic.
>
> If that individual even exists, he's a fuckwit.
>
>> The part of the car  where you get to the shocks is close thespeakers,
>> so they must have  been very rough with it.
>
> Not even possible with the shocks outside
> the car and the speakers inside it, fuckwit.
>
>> The car audio guy said it was as though therehad been a fire in that
>> area of the car.
>
> Retake Trolling 101
>
>> Since the speakers only didn't work after I picked up the car from the
>> mechanic, it is too much of a coincidence that wasn't the mechanic who
>> broke the speakers.
>
> Retake Trolling 101

So what you are saying is because I have trolled before, I cannot ask
any legitimate question?

Max <max@val.morgan> wrote
> Rod Speed wrote
>> Max <max@val.morgan> wrote
>>> Rod Speed wrote
>>>> Max <max@val.morgan> wrote
>>>>> Rod Speed wrote
>>>>>> Max <max@val.morgan> wrote

>>>>>>> I went to a mechanic, part of a large chain of mechanics, and got
>>>>>>> some work done they said needed doing (rear shocks).
>>>>
>>>>>>> When I picked up the car the speakers didn't work anymore.
>>>>
>>>>>>> I took the car to a car audio guy and he said something has
>>>>>>> damaged the rear speakers. I said the mechanic replaced the rear
>>>>>>> shocks, and he said it must have been when that happened.
>>>>
>>>>>> SURE you did.
>>>>
>>>>>>> Can I demand the mechanic pays the cost of the speaker
>>>>>>> replacement, due to the mechanic having broken the speakers,
>>>>>>> according to the car audio guy?
>>>>
>>>>>> Its bullshit, replacing the rear shocks wouldnt fuck the speakers.
>>>>
>>>>> The rear shocks are near the rear speakers. It's likely the
>>>>> mechanic was rough trying to access the shocks and damaged the
>>>>> speakers.
>>
>>>> Pity the speakers are inside the car and the shocks arent.
>>
>>> The car audio guy it must have been the mechanic.
>> If that individual even exists, he's a fuckwit.
>>
>>> The part of the car where you get to the shocks is close thespeakers,
>>> so they must have been very rough with it.
>> Not even possible with the shocks outside
>> the car and the speakers inside it, fuckwit.
>>
>>> The car audio guy said it was as though therehad been a fire in that
>>> area of the car.
>> Retake Trolling 101
>>
>>> Since the speakers only didn't work after I picked up the car from the
>>> mechanic, it is too much of a coincidence that wasn't the mechanic who
>>> broke the speakers.
>> Retake Trolling 101

> So what you are saying is because I have trolled before, I cannot ask
> any legitimate question?

Nope, that you are clearly trolling again.