Message-ID:

"Go to Heaven for the climate, Hell for the company." -- Mark Twain

devel / comp.lang.python / Re: Behavior of the for-else construct

Re: Behavior of the for-else construct

<mailman.136.1646348884.2329.python-list@python.org>

https://www.novabbs.com/devel/article-flat.php?id=17313&group=comp.lang.python#17313

copy link Newsgroups: comp.lang.python

Path: i2pn2.org!i2pn.org!news.swapon.de!fu-berlin.de!uni-berlin.de!not-for-mail
From: avigr...@verizon.net (Avi Gross)
Newsgroups: comp.lang.python
Subject: Re: Behavior of the for-else construct
Date: Thu, 3 Mar 2022 23:07:59 +0000 (UTC)
Lines: 85
Message-ID: <mailman.136.1646348884.2329.python-list@python.org>
References: <CALq4Z0-fJk-HOu0ka2kPrOioPYAh3e3zbziwetUDmAAx1U1LMw@mail.gmail.com>
<YiFCPlGC+2aRIR0K@shallowsky.com>
<21739669.459456.1646348879560@mail.yahoo.com>
Reply-To: Avi Gross <avigross@verizon.net>
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
X-Trace: news.uni-berlin.de NGSifBdmYBGplC0yjiZ/lwpQV4uQ2v6Y9i4y3uWRMhrQ==
Return-Path: <avigross@verizon.net>
X-Original-To: python-list@python.org
Delivered-To: python-list@mail.python.org
Authentication-Results: mail.python.org; dkim=pass
reason="2048-bit key; unprotected key"
header.d=verizon.net header.i=@verizon.net header.b=Q1N+hSeQ;
dkim-adsp=pass; dkim-atps=neutral
X-Spam-Status: OK 0.018
X-Spam-Evidence: '*H*': 0.96; '*S*': 0.00; 'python?': 0.03; '2022':
0.05; 'fairly': 0.05; 'else.': 0.07; 'exit': 0.07; 'loop': 0.07;
'mar': 0.07; 'used.': 0.07; 'construct': 0.09; 'else:': 0.09;
'emacs': 0.09; 'ended': 0.09; 'it)': 0.09; 'operators': 0.09;
'readable': 0.09; 'writes:': 0.09; 'url:mailman': 0.15; 'does,':
0.16; 'flow.': 0.16; 'instead.': 0.16; 'order?': 0.16; 'recall':
0.16; 'reminds': 0.16; 'sentences,': 0.16; 'subject:else': 0.16;
'triggered': 0.16; 'typing': 0.16; 'wrapper': 0.16; 'instead':
0.17; 'implement': 0.19; 'thu,': 0.19; 'to:addr:python-list':
0.20; 'language': 0.21; 'languages': 0.22; 'version': 0.23;
'code': 0.23; 'to:name:python-list@python.org': 0.24; 'skip:- 10':
0.25; 'url-ip:188.166.95.178/32': 0.25; 'url-ip:188.166.95/24':
0.25; 'url:listinfo': 0.25; 'url-ip:188.166/16': 0.25; 'anyone':
0.25; 'seems': 0.26; 'behavior': 0.26; 'leave': 0.27; 'else':
0.27; 'bit': 0.27; 'function': 0.27; 'sense': 0.28; 'it,': 0.29;
'code,': 0.31; 'url-ip:188/8': 0.31; 'wondering': 0.31; "doesn't":
0.32; 'context': 0.32; 'language.': 0.32; 'requests,': 0.32;
'signal': 0.32; 'specified': 0.32; 'words,': 0.32; "wouldn't":
0.32; 'but': 0.32; 'subject:for': 0.33; 'there': 0.33;
'particular': 0.33; 'someone': 0.34; 'same': 0.34; "didn't": 0.34;
'header:In-Reply-To:1': 0.34; 'running': 0.34; 'people': 0.36;
'really': 0.37; 'hard': 0.37; 'could': 0.38; 'means': 0.38;
'read': 0.38; 'changes': 0.39; 'quite': 0.39; 'added': 0.39;
'adding': 0.39; 'use': 0.39; 'break': 0.39; 'still': 0.40;
'difficult': 0.40; 'wants': 0.40; 'both': 0.40; 'something': 0.40;
'want': 0.40; 'should': 0.40; 'remember': 0.61; 'here.': 0.61;
'above': 0.62; 'from:': 0.62; 'to:': 0.62; 'forward': 0.62;
'ever': 0.63; 'simply': 0.63; 'once': 0.63; 'imagine': 0.64;
're:': 0.64; 'your': 0.64; 'look': 0.65; 'worked': 0.67; 'back':
0.67; 'caught': 0.67; 'items': 0.68; 'conditions': 0.70; 'survey':
0.71; 'little': 0.73; 'easy': 0.74; 'non': 0.75; 'hearing': 0.75;
'....': 0.76; 'sponsored': 0.76; 'sent:': 0.78; 'header:Reply-
To:1': 0.79; 'up,': 0.84; 'bind': 0.84; 'desperately': 0.84;
'entered': 0.84; 'implies': 0.84; 'macro': 0.84; 'signals': 0.84;
'signs': 0.84; 'was.': 0.84; 'expensive': 0.91; 'mind,': 0.93;
'cut': 0.95
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=verizon.net; s=a2048;
t=1646348881; bh=0cnEU3irtIGmU1CQAfVaei4dkEf0OLCUPrlNL90Mr/0=;
h=Date:From:Reply-To:To:In-Reply-To:References:Subject:From:Subject:Reply-To;
b=Q1N+hSeQSjFHrbPe75+pA14oRdFDi4ZPf6+yqNcQDn+ZgEcmPjqnTjbFOR5fLqUHIkGdLpasXeX9HgJ5R4zE1mksInl9FMZuv0SYtl4jkiB5LUjPcK56ED6YaQXwuyByRdri++67I+sv5V7y+w/uZONJcyqUMj8+Bf0tBcteXMw9dLd3QazzAhcFQuhLxJPOjFgPeHMhwcU+Ka4Gfuf2IzG46ZaEBbGdgWRPbC87XzY21C4PY0Mm10pKeep5DWR9tEtrf5YV7JPlTD1+TX4W3n6W/7pFW/8XidNqtbYHmPx38nkQXaNaKT9+2T/xeamKwhNnTuh3RyndbMV77SXjfQ==
X-SONIC-DKIM-SIGN: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=yahoo.com; s=s2048;
t=1646348881; bh=KOfdsrG9uuEsuEsxz686M0pTpJckuZMth1HMMpNyfmo=;
h=X-Sonic-MF:Date:From:To:Subject:From:Subject;
b=pjsb3H//d3cxmfFiiDe9/636vTokiA3h6OIxAUyFxoeOO2Cx8Atu0hHJmUEbMGIFNSk28xq3a1D2P8ifaUQyIzIjNpGPQhar1+iHDS0UmsSeBq5n8KXXsQtmw87pWGa8rUCfwgMPLsumCB8NoaHVhGZ2rbwNI2hBdY7Vwa7KzWMPREQaIQnn4eGLossok6bKZycocNKTvRhYWU3UKBKOiL1L1NhEgMUZulAondcdzG7hQBVeXy9YN23dMwhQpg+RlH5qRu8uXV1jViYx8klT4j/sAl6ERHae4NzSx9qtrtjc43Pfqzebqi0QzZrLmq2ng7cgUq+qLBAbm2PUmzQOzw==
X-YMail-OSG: FYG2y8AVM1nKkRQcqZIrsj0xRHrY8gmlcP64Fmc8ISkNZA9P3uaQt0yvtlG_oUx
EW6KMfDZB9Q9FvOvRgxvecTghkuF93zhcCHcH5aUSN1mudO_T9i7NfaVIklMDiE5HSSm8ZSQB6Qz
i1g2.k1W9xf1vyMSabAD.SQYGebnSXrcG5ItFy4j1G6pL6aqBEc.XHL_yUfVFjV1N_QS1ce_8jWk
m6eIhwQJYpbWat3cTtp8gN_1DUVEtpl2xJGB5mXAAuuEBuKrSTJ80ZSOHKMU3NfbmYKoU06fseVM
AVUBoV.y6DjxWiLIYkhzb_OtvK2qtFqBSkevmFzFv_DcHpaQv_6ORvLtgSbIqe15TLuR8BYwN4W4
R1VPTmH2EQTuUV_5QEsCoC_EqoaJd16NuAzE6MQ.GEO6evFhhDWvuW6alv0sFYq3nSwiS5XtvuT7
.G9AGJMzuA04flARkdvdg0m1nwhGsh77NWyRDbNtMGQfyeLErJP9DfRqM4h.1KzwPyoaqUjaQ9BK
HD07j_E0dbVsXq68.LlFc_f9Dd9OZw0MH2sUcJXNndwcFAGbX9rYNTH.5eyIO4kpUhxspls.rzVG
iyusn1CyFfvOCSaU_mxvkCneQ1kLPaWbosGLeyv8o2vjvPyo2UkiAfpVhRbA.p2MScD3k2Pj_NHk
z_rhOB6rqmTFH6aO2hgq1S7wxeG20DqhOR71zUUxS3GdbeNUYyuSUTZ9YeGjG_NZ_qzTmGnO7szM
e2Pj2nBg0p9Q3utUo0NzLp4UZIILvJsH130WPMVwTWWBlcFWn2ZEOROSB3hXpaZFRYP5_UUQhc2F
CcHgLLYAbFzPwSSRg9lAqlYQx8_LyWRCB3e6BvN9HSrdEXeNHBS08UWlJQGQwFbFMutba2Tm5rqM
AVWa5JjYYP4l7sunR9CvUDLY6Z7QWQ3COfy0T3qUTpzuqv8tbsNtBrF02HTOulBhHH_QYWxXjTaJ
h1jfP4wUvnzNFXtxEw3wXvPjUXr2.2ul8c0.TgSajKfOJFfASQVyHHevjxVPs.jG2cpAqu5qWmjt
uvRPsEKMDmmyvsuxTZPjPlS5tn7G1tUkFicMFoi519LG2uqdTPphaGqU9DwDqkeS8NcAud.uaVd9
yqHHMkgi8TDmbyne2eC4oXFnvI38LSwsjUpfbZGq1MHHOOXvuL._4oUEg2cSXEiNHqouJCMoDVxV
KWu.VM6UWoakMQNRD65GjtpBvI1gl6GLSDSjdhTo4P9fC31o9a0drRRLFVNSY.UnvC6S1KBXqvdl
KzKm8O4eLLUSHevXIlYAbKIrQ8SDMCczVeQchm5hsHqZPBaoNDRdnnXQip9F.EcxG_huH9eKXNqZ
fuSXvgA1A0y3C2jnYgNRI4y3AFma_FlvZ1fLLN6f1FQz.6W15FVqGmYAE_LoqTJyN1KKtv1SQsZG
C7Ypiy_VJb94fNE8waDywjk7kRHL8rvUuX4mdbng2CZ7wyOa9mWEMbsYNH7j2TTszWokZZ0zmVkm
ynNk6mbURQWjC8VVFV_RhT2Ae3Us1LoFC4AtelfPsdQY18MnPY7kYnR5B3Y6mVLNsqY7__zfh0G5
G4rnIH6j4MNsG4Ze0C48IbD9uEvDp3AsuJIIRssrVOCsdLaT7T6dEGEx0IOWPPnTBoj40olTZo9y
3Ap1rF1Sx2515.WR22imc54RCBInIjjobloKv0SOWm78VPjHPVkNXtKQqaxpkkUTYXGgR7kDjt.M
lqSwLKkeAl1z2_J320OHcl3UEkIVAddFPimNsrFa7vLvfqsjPy8ZJOWszyJ537Xs.Fuwd7AbF8Xu
x47gdDkT5ZorxbOtWj5FUvRLPwBQS_fL9.nte_DsKpKf.tL0Ke4J2MAxM3PDcZCUYWpjp4HQKoGh
VeNtMAm7TdlIlCJCmtklGHk2VS5SGRX.jJd7cHTamP_TEj8kvDy.syuJYmG59Kin9chE0Q7Yd.wO
pYNK6b2BevpXrxzkJJtupUM1jSa94ViGuZYXCvUHiIBq6xcmB3ETODjDGACyBUue4mLFmSGKewtn
C984zsRi49wO3JgPskrs_DkWLTWb_jblyJCNqT4OG8vnQDYGlvUuxGAvIKPwMPJFptZ_o7pl1lG5
.EYXMXbyL81V4IRA.Jk8WbdvmBliCdseM9LsVUOPyrQhcq2M5PgbBnNVgA_gO1XwXgJ4nKw7p8Oy
cqLsGqHuqfW.xBC8Sh2SpLYSH3b6QrTK9qNqwiJPA3dtFag298TwfkuihMH4sXOs4V9KVFDscrgj
4lKyQ6XRow8H97ftRbrfBuugZUw--
X-Sonic-MF: <avigross@verizon.net>
In-Reply-To: <YiFCPlGC+2aRIR0K@shallowsky.com>
X-Mailer: WebService/1.1.19724 aolwebmail
X-BeenThere: python-list@python.org
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.39
Precedence: list
List-Id: General discussion list for the Python programming language
<python-list.python.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <https://mail.python.org/mailman/options/python-list>,
<mailto:python-list-request@python.org?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <https://mail.python.org/pipermail/python-list/>
List-Post: <mailto:python-list@python.org>
List-Help: <mailto:python-list-request@python.org?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <https://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list>,
<mailto:python-list-request@python.org?subject=subscribe>
X-Mailman-Original-Message-ID: <21739669.459456.1646348879560@mail.yahoo.com>
X-Mailman-Original-References: <CALq4Z0-fJk-HOu0ka2kPrOioPYAh3e3zbziwetUDmAAx1U1LMw@mail.gmail.com>
<YiFCPlGC+2aRIR0K@shallowsky.com>

by: Avi Gross - Thu, 3 Mar 2022 23:07 UTC

The drumbeat I keep hearing is that some people hear/see the same word as implying something else. ELSE is ambiguous in the context it is used.

And naturally, since nobody desperately wants to use non-reserved keywords, nobody seems ready to use a word like INSTEAD instead.

Ideally, a language should be extendable and some languages like R allow you to place all kinds of things inside percent signs to make new operators like %*% or %PIPE% ...

Just because some feature may be wanted is not a good reason to overly complicate a language. Can you imagine how hard it would be both to implement and read something like:

....
ELSE:
...
OK:
...
FINALLY:
...
ULTIMATELY:
...

What if multiple of things like the above example need to be triggered in some particular order?

I have to wonder if some new form of wrapper might have made as much sense as in you wrap your loop in something that sets up and traps various signals that are then produced under conditions specified such as the loop not being entered as the starting condition is sort of null, or an exit due to a break or simply because the code itself throws that signal to be caught ...

This reminds me a bit of how some programs add so much functionality because someone thought of it without wondering if anyone (including the ones who sponsored it) would ever want to use it or remember it is there or how. I recall how a version of emacs had a transpose-letter function so after typing "teh" you could hit control-t and a little mock LISP macro would go back and co a cut and go forward and do a paste and leave the cursor where it was. That was sometimes useful, but often just as easy to backspace and retype. But I recall gleefully adding a transpose for words, sentences, paragraphs and was going to add more but I was running out of keystrokes to bind them to and besides it can be fairly easy to select items and yank them and move to where you want them and replace them.

To make changes in a language is sometimes really expensive but also dangerous. A "free" language must be added to sparingly and with so many requests, perhaps only a few non bug-fixes can seriously be considered.

-----Original Message-----
From: Akkana Peck <akkana@shallowsky.com>
To: python-list@python.org
Sent: Thu, Mar 3, 2022 5:33 pm
Subject: Re: Behavior of the for-else construct

computermaster360 writes:
> I want to make a little survey here.
>
> Do you find the for-else construct useful?

No.

> Have you used it in practice?

Once or twice, but ended up removing it, see below.

> Do you even know how it works, or that there is such a thing in Python?

I always have to look it up, because to my mind, "else" implies
it does something quite different from what it actually does.

Which means that even if I worked hard at memorizing what it does,
so I didn't have to look it up, I still wouldn't use it in code,
because I want my code to be easily readable (including by future-me).
for..else makes code difficult to understand by anyone who doesn't
use for..else frequently: they might be misled into misunderstanding
the control flow.

...Akkana

--
https://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list

Subject	Author
Re: Behavior of the for-else construct	Avi Gross