He proposed an alternative motion theory
he called Closing velocity.
The twin contradiction doesn't happen
in his alternative.
Contradictions in theory disprove it.

On Wednesday, May 17, 2023 at 11:26:35 PM UTC+5, mitchr...@gmail.com wrote:
> He proposed an alternative motion theory
> he called Closing velocity.
> The twin contradiction doesn't happen
> in his alternative.
> Contradictions in theory disprove it.

Any references? Here is one interesting fact:

"The routine analyses of the Fizeau experiment and of stellar aberration, that treat light as Newtonian corpuscles, do not require relativity."

######
However, all of the above is supposition. In later recollections, when Einstein was asked about what inspired him to develop special relativity, he would mention his riding a light beam and his magnet and conductor thought experiments. He would also mention the importance of the Fizeau experiment and the observation of stellar aberration. "They were enough", he said.[18] He never mentioned thought experiments about clocks and their synchronization.[16]

The routine analyses of the Fizeau experiment and of stellar aberration, that treat light as Newtonian corpuscles, do not require relativity. But problems arise if one considers light as waves traveling through an aether, which are resolved by applying the relativity of simultaneity. It is entirely possible, therefore, that Einstein arrived at special relativity through a different path than that commonly assumed, through Einstein's examination of Fizeau's experiment and stellar aberration.[16]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein%27s_thought_experiments
######